Applying to College in the USA

Applying to College in the USA

Applying to colleges in the United States is a multifaceted process that demands thorough preparation and attention to detail.

This guide provides a step-by-step approach to navigating the college application process in the USA.

Understanding the US Higher Education System

For many UK students, the main attraction of studying in the United States is flexibility. Rather than applying for a single subject, you usually apply to a university or a broad school (such as Arts & Sciences) and then explore different disciplines before choosing a major – your main area of study. Most students declare their major at the end of their first or second year.

American universities vary widely in size and atmosphere:

Public universities are typically large, government-funded institutions with extensive facilities and a wide range of courses.

Private universities may be smaller but often combine large lectures with small seminars and well-resourced campuses.

Liberal arts colleges are usually the smallest, focusing on undergraduate teaching, close academic support and broad-based study across the humanities, social sciences and sciences.

In US usage, “college” and “university” are often interchangeable. Both award undergraduate degrees, though universities usually also offer postgraduate programmes.

When to Begin the Application Process

The US admissions process runs over several years, so starting early helps enormously. Most UK students begin researching options toward the end of Year 11 or early in Year 12. By the summer before Year 13, applicants are usually drafting essays and refining their college lists.

US universities offer several application rounds:

• Early Action (EA) – usually around 1 November; you apply early but are not committed to attend if admitted.
• Early Decision (ED) – also around 1 November; this round is binding, so if admitted you must enrol and withdraw other applications.
• Early Decision II (ED II) – a second binding early round, typically in January.
• Regular Decision (RD) – deadlines in early to mid-January; most international students apply in this round.

Some highly selective institutions, such as Harvard, Yale, Princeton and Stanford, use Single Choice Early Action (SCEA). This is non-binding but restricts you to one early application to a private university, making it a strategic choice if you have a clear favourite.

Understanding these options early allows you to decide whether you want to apply early to a first-choice institution or focus entirely on the Regular Decision round.

Building an Effective US College List

A well-constructed college list is crucial. Unlike UCAS, where you apply to a small number of courses, US applicants typically submit between 8 and 12 applications. This volume makes it especially important to be strategic.

Most students divide their list into three categories:

• Reach schools – highly selective institutions where admission is never guaranteed, even for top students.
• Target schools – universities where your grades (and test scores, if submitted) broadly match those of typical admitted students.
• Safety schools – places where your academic profile is clearly above the usual admitted range and where you would be genuinely happy to enrol.

When comparing universities, try to look beyond the name. Consider:

• Academic strengths and likely areas of interest
• Size and typical class experience
• Location and setting (city, suburb, small town)
• Campus culture and student support
• Extracurricular and research opportunities
• Financial aid and scholarship policies

Many students begin with a long list in Year 11, then narrow it throughout Year 12 as they learn more. By the start of Year 13, you should have a balanced list and a clear idea of where you may apply early.

Standardised Testing: SAT and ACT

Standardised tests have become less rigidly required, but they are still an important part of US admissions for many universities. Some institutions are now test-optional, others test-free, and some still require scores. Strong SAT or ACT results can be especially helpful for international students, as they provide a familiar benchmark for admissions teams.

The SAT focuses on reading, writing and maths. The ACT covers similar content but includes an additional science reasoning section and tends to feel faster paced. These are the key differences between the SAT and ACT. Neither exam is “easier”; students usually find that one format suits their strengths better.

A common approach is:

• Early Year 12: sit full-length practice tests for both SAT and ACT.
• Mid to late Year 12: choose one exam and sit it at least once, with the option of a retake if helpful.

If you decide not to submit scores at test-optional universities, other elements – grades, transcript, extracurriculars and essays – must carry more weight. Checking each university’s current testing policy is essential, as approaches differ.

Many students take extra SAT prep or ACT prep – whether in the form of tutoring or courses – to help get ready. At Dukes Plus, our prep services are proven to substantially boost students’ scores.

Academic Requirements and the UK School Transcript

US universities look at your academic record over several years, not just final exams. Your school transcript therefore matters just as much as your predicted grades. This document usually lists:

• GCSE results
• Year 12 grades
• Predicted A level, IB or other qualification results
• Notes on your school’s grading system, where necessary

Because transcripts are not standard in the UK, many schools prepare them specifically for US applications. Admissions officers use them to assess consistency and progression over time.

US universities are familiar with A levels, the IB Diploma, Scottish Highers and other UK qualifications. They evaluate these within context rather than directly converting them into a US-style GPA. A strong record of challenging courses and solid grades across multiple years makes a powerful impression.

Extracurricular Activities (ECs)

Extracurricular activities are a defining feature of US admissions. Universities want students who will contribute actively to campus life, so what you do outside the classroom matters.

Depth is more important than sheer volume. Two or three sustained commitments over several years will usually be more compelling than a long list of short-lived clubs. Examples include:

• Sport, music or drama at school or club level
• Volunteering or charity work
• Leadership roles (prefect, society officer, team captain)
• Academic clubs, competitions or independent projects
• Part-time work or caring responsibilities

Admissions officers look for impact: have you taken on responsibility, shown initiative, developed expertise or made a difference to others? When you apply, you will list your activities and briefly describe your role in each, giving context to your time commitments and achievements.

Extracurriculars also provide rich material for essays and help teachers write specific, persuasive references.

Understanding the Common Application

The Common Application (Common App) is the main platform used by US universities. It allows you to complete one core application and send it to multiple institutions.

Key sections include:

• Personal and family information
• School and academic history
• Extracurricular activities and honours
• Your Common App personal essay
• Teacher and counsellor recommendations, submitted separately by the school

Some questions, such as class rank or GPA, may not apply to UK students; it is perfectly acceptable to indicate that your school does not provide this information.

Not all universities use the Common App. The University of California system, MIT, Georgetown and a few others run their own application platforms with separate essays and forms.

The Common App opens each year on 1 August. Many students use the summer to set up their account, complete basic sections and draft their main essay, so that once Year 13 begins they can focus on university-specific questions.

Writing the Common App Personal Essay

The Common App personal essay (up to 650 words) is your chance to speak directly to admissions officers in your own voice. It is quite different from a UCAS personal statement. Rather than proving your academic suitability for one subject, you are encouraged to tell a story that reveals something important about you – your background, values, interests or way of thinking.

The prompts are intentionally broad. You might write about a challenge you have faced, a moment of curiosity, a project, a relationship, or an experience that changed your perspective. The topic does not need to be dramatic; small, specific stories often work best.

Most students begin drafting in the summer before Year 13. This gives time to:

• Brainstorm ideas and choose a direction
• Draft and redraft without last-minute pressure
• Ask for feedback on clarity and tone

A strong essay adds something new to your application rather than repeating your activities list. It should help admissions officers understand who you are as a person, not just what you have done.

Supplemental Essays

Many universities ask for supplemental essays in addition to the Common App essay. These are short responses, usually 50–250 words, that focus on university-specific questions.

Common themes include:

• “Why this university?”
• “Why this course or academic interest?”
• Your community, background or values
• Examples of curiosity, leadership or creativity

These essays are crucial at selective institutions because they show how seriously you have researched your choices. Strong answers are specific: they mention particular courses, teaching approaches, opportunities or aspects of campus life that genuinely appeal to you.

Because each university has its own set of questions, the total writing load can be substantial. Many students begin drafting supplements as soon as prompts become available in August and work on them steadily through the autumn.

References and Recommendations

Teacher and school recommendations help admissions officers understand you in context. Most universities request:

• One school/counsellor reference (often from a Head of Year or tutor)
• One or two teacher references from subjects you have studied in depth

Good references speak about your intellectual curiosity, classroom engagement and character rather than simply listing grades.

It’s sensible to approach potential referees towards the end of Year 12, explain your plans, and provide a short CV or activities list. References are submitted directly by the school through the Common App or the university’s own system and are not normally visible to students.

Interviews

Some universities, particularly more selective ones, offer optional interviews, often conducted by alumni. These are usually informal conversations rather than formal tests.

Interviews typically explore:

• Your academic interests and reasons for studying in the US
• Experiences or activities that matter to you
• What attracts you to that specific university

They are also a chance for you to ask questions and get a sense of the institution beyond the website. Preparing by reading about the university and reflecting on your interests will help you speak confidently and naturally.

While interviews rarely determine the outcome alone, they can reinforce the positive impressions created elsewhere in your application.

Submitting Your Applications

Once your essays, references and transcript are ready, you submit your applications via the Common App or the relevant university platform. Each institution sets its own deadline, so a clear checklist is essential, especially if you are applying in multiple rounds.

Before you press submit, check:

• Personal and school information
• Activities and honours entries
• Essay formatting and content
• That your referees have been invited correctly

After submission, universities usually create an online portal where you can track whether all materials – including references and test scores, if applicable – have been received. Because items are processed at different speeds, it’s normal for some to appear “pending” for a few days.

Most universities charge an application fee, though fee waivers are available for eligible students. You pay per institution, so it is worth budgeting carefully if you plan to apply widely.

Decisions, Offers, and Next Steps

Decision timelines depend on the round:

• EA/ED decisions usually arrive in December
• ED II decisions typically arrive in February
• RD decisions are released from March to early April

You may receive:

• An offer of admission – binding if from ED; non-binding if from EA or RD.
• A deferral – your early application is moved into the Regular Decision pool.
• A waitlist place – you may be admitted later if spaces become available.
• A rejection – final for that cycle.

If admitted through Early Decision, you are expected to enrol and withdraw other applications. For non-binding offers, you normally have until 1 May (College Decision Day) to make your final choice.

The period from March to May is your chance to compare academic fit, campus environment and any financial aid packages before committing.

Finances and Funding

Studying in the US can be expensive, and costs vary significantly between institutions. Typical expenses include:

• Tuition
• Accommodation and meals
• Books and supplies
• Health insurance and general living costs

Many universities offer financial support to international students, but policies differ. Broadly, funding comes in two main forms:

• Need-based financial aid – based on your family’s financial circumstances. International students usually apply via the CSS Profile.
• Merit-based scholarships – awarded for academic excellence, leadership, artistic or athletic talent, or other achievements.

Some well-resourced universities offer generous need-based aid to international students, while others provide limited or no funding, so it is vital to check each institution’s policy early. When offers arrive, comparing the total cost of attendance and any aid packages will help you decide where you can enrol comfortably.

Suggested Timeline (Years 11–13)

A clear timeline makes the process far more manageable.

Year 11

Explore whether studying in the US interests you. Read about different types of institutions, and start building a small number of sustained extracurricular commitments.

Year 12

Refine your college list and research entry expectations. Take practice SAT and ACT exams and, if you decide to test, schedule your first sitting. Maintain strong grades and keep developing your extracurricular profile. By the end of the year, aim to have a provisional college list and activities overview.

Summer before Year 13

Draft your Common App personal essay and set up your Common App account. Review supplemental essay prompts as they are released. Confirm your referees and ensure your school understands transcript and deadline requirements.

Year 13

Finalise essays and complete application forms. Submit EA/ED applications around 1 November if applying early, and RD applications by early to mid-January. Keep grades strong, monitor portals, and check that all documents are received. From March to May, review decisions and financial aid offers and make your final choice by 1 May.

This timeline is only a guide, but starting early and spreading tasks over time will make the US application process far less stressful and allow you to present your strongest possible application.

Speak to an Expert